Re: [Libguestfs] [PATCH 6/7] v2v: quiet virtio net and balloon devices wizards
On Wed, Apr 06, 2016 at 10:13:35AM +0200, Cedric Bosdonnat wrote:
The problem with running after the PnP is that user will be prompted
for installation of virtio-net and virtio-balloon drivers... which
doesn't make sense as we are going to install them automatically
anyway.
[...]
Some versions of windows (2008 IIRC) are explicitly waiting for user
input in the PnP wizard: the best it not to show the PnP dialogs for
the virtio devices to the user at all.
I tend to agree that not prompting the user here provides better user
experience; however I don't feel like this is a major issue.
Regardless of the severity of the problem, the solution you propose --
disabling the prompts for specific device instance IDs -- is IMO way too
unreliable and PnP manager will still want to interact in a number of
common cases:
- if the devices get enumerated differently and Windows assigns
different instance IDs to them
- if there's more than one device of any kind
- if there are new devices beyond those you handle (e.g. virtio-serial)
I think this would be better addressed if you could disable PnP manager
prompts globally during v2v, and reset it back in a firstboot script
after your installer had been run.
Roman.