пн, 10 лют. 2020 о 14:59 Richard W.M. Jones <rjones@redhat.com> пише:
On Mon, Feb 10, 2020 at 02:22:01PM +0200, Nikolay Ivanets wrote:
Here are what they do stand for: physical_block_size: The physical block size the disk will report to the guest OS. For Linux this would be the value returned by the BLKPBSZGET ioctl and describes the disk's hardware sector size which can be relevant for the alignment of disk data. We don't have an API to get this one.
logical_block_size: The logical block size the disk will report to the guest OS. For Linux this would be the value returned by the BLKSSZGET ioctl and describes the smallest units for disk I/O. We have blockdev-getsz API to get this value.
Interestingly parted uses BLKSSZGET (logical_block_size), but does not use BLKPBSZGET (physical_block_size), so I guess that fits with my observations.
How do they use. If your HDD has physical block size = 4096 you might want make I/O request equals to (or multiple) this value. Otherwise you might hit performance penalty. I think, the same is valid for virtual disk image which is located on physical storage with 4K physical sector size. ... Here are possible combinations of [pl]blocksize in real world:
physical | logical ----------------------- 4096 | 4096 4096 | 512 512 | 512
Having both values equals works except for case #2 which will not impact on functionality, only performance might be hit. If we want to simplify our API - we might expose the only parameter called 'blocksize' and set physical_block_size and logical_block_size to the same value.
Right, but libguestfs rarely deals with real physical disks. I think even if eg. you attach libguestfs to /dev/sdX there's still going to be a host kernel in between doing its thing. So I'm not clear that the 4K physical / 512b logical case is actually something that libguestfs cares about. (But OTOH I'm also not clear why qemu cares about this case either.)
I think because QEMU emulates real hardware. And on real hardware you can get different physical/logical block size. So QEMU allows you to create such a configuration. -- Mykola Ivanets